Résumés
Abstract
Donald Trump has been a godsend for those of us who teach critical thinking. For he is a fount of manipulative rhetoric, glaring fallacies, conspiracy theories, fake news, and bullshit. In this paper I draw on my own recent teaching experience in order to discuss both the usefulness and the limits of using Trump examples in teaching critical thinking. In Section One I give the framework of the course; in Section Two I indicate Trump’s relevance to many important concepts in the course; and in Section Three I argue that critical thinking instructors should restrain themselves from overreliance on Trump-examples.
Résumé
Donald Trump a été une aubaine pour ceux d'entre nous qui enseignent la pensée critique. Car il est une source de rhétorique manipulatrice, de sophismes flagrants, de théories du complot, de fausses nouvelles et de conneries. Dans cet article, je me base sur ma propre expérience d'enseignement afin de discuter à la fois de l'utilité et des limites de l'utilisation des exemples de Trump dans la formation de la pensée critique. Dans la première partie, je donne le cadre du cours ; dans la deuxième section, j'indique la pertinence de Trump dans l’enseignement de nombreux concepts importants du cours; et dans la troisième section, je soutiens que les instructeurs de la pensée critique devraient se retenir de trop se fier aux exemples de Trump.
Veuillez télécharger l’article en PDF pour le lire.
Télécharger
Parties annexes
Bibliography
- Baker, Peter and Maggie Haberman. 5 March 2017. A conspiracy theory’s journey from talk radio to Trump’s Twitter. New York Times.
- Coppins, McKay. July 2017. How the left lost its mind. The Atlantic.
- Dionne, E.J. 1 March 2017. Trump still wants you to be very, very afraid. Washington Post.
- Drum, Kevin. 24 January 2017. What does it take to finally call a lie a lie? We have an answer. Mother Jones.
- Frankfurt, Harry. 2005. Bullshit. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
- Frankfurt, Harry. 12 May 2016. Donald Trump is BS, says expert in BS. Time.
- Full Text. 15 August 2017. Full text: Trump’s comments on white supremacists, “alt-left” in Charlottesville. URL accessed 20 August 2017: www.politico.com/story/2017/08/15.
- Goldmacher, Shane. 15 May 2015. How Trump gets his fake news. URL accessed 12 June 2016: www.politico.com/story/2017/05/15.
- Hardiman, Kate. 9 November 2015. Ad hominem politics. URL accessed 12 December 2016: ndsmcobserver.com/kate-hardiman.
- Kessler, Glenn, Meg Kelly and Nicole Lewish. 1 January 2018. President Trump has made 1,950 false or misleading claims over 347 days. Washington Post.
- Khazan, Olga. 2 February 2017. Why Fake News Targeted Trump Supporters. The Atlantic.
- Krugman, Paul. 20 March 2017. America’s Epidemic of Infallibility. New York Times.
- Lee, Jasmine C. and Kevin Quealy. 25 August 2017. The 363 people, places, and things Donald Trump has insulted on Twitter: A complete list. New York Times.
- Lee, Michelle Ye Hee. 8 July 2015. Donald Trump’s false comments concerning immigrants and crime. Washington Post.
- Leonhardt, David. 31 May 2017. Lies vs. B.S. New York Times.
- Leonhardt, David and Stuart A. Thompson. 14 December 2017. Trump’s lies: The definitive list. New York Times.
- MacGuill, Dan. 12 July 2017. The lies of Donald Trump’s critics, and how they shape his many personas. URL accessed 8 August 2017: www.snopes.com.
- Milbank, Dana. 3 March 2017. It’s the truth according to Trump. Believe it. Washington Post.
- Moore, Brooke Noel and Richard Parker. 2015. Critical Thinking. 11th edition. New York. McGraw-Hill.
- Myer, Robinson. February 2017. The rise of progressive “fake news.” The Atlantic.
- Rosenberg, Alyssa. 29 June 2017. Why I’m grateful every time President Trump insults a woman. Washington Post.
- Tannen, Deborah. 9 June 2017. It’s not just Trump’s message that matters. There’s also his metamessage. Washington Post.
- Tashman, Brian. 7 February 2016. Donald Trump keeps pushing Alex Jones’ conspiracy theories. URL accessed 9 February 2016: www.rightwingwatch.org.
- Thrush, Glenn and Maggie Haberman. 12 August 2017. Trump is criticized for not calling out white supremacists. New York Times.
- Zak, Dan. 8 August 2017. Whataboutism: The Cold War tactic, thawed by Putin, is brandished by Donald Trump. Washington Post.